Response to Makaella's Blog:

-
Makaella, I think you offer good insight here when you say progress is arbitrary. I personally don't think that progress can be defined in the global perspective, because progress means different things for different countries. I also don't think that it should be defined, because that can lead to a superiority complex, one that I think the United States has always possessed. The United States defines progress in industrial and technological terms. Some countries aren't as advanced in these aspects, but are much more developed in culture. Since the United States defines progress in different terms that the other country lacks, they view themselves as superior, when really the other country is superior in other aspects. Who is to judge who is inferior or superior?
This is something that I have always had a problem with throughout my life, and especially lately since I have entered this class. People talk about different cultures and how they are inferior to our own but really, who is to judge another culture? How can we define something as inferior or superior? Every culture is its own entity and it should be respected as such, not looked down upon. What even is American culture? How can we look down upon other developed cultures when they are just as valid as our own?
Thanks for writing your blog!

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Liberation Theology: Bringing the Church and Religion Together

-
          During Professor Stark's lecture on Monday, there was something that really caught my attention, and it was the concept of Liberation Theology. Professor Stark defined it as "using religion to empower people to change the world" (my notes), which I think is an interesting concept. I further researched it, and the definition further expanded. Liberation Theology calls for the "true" followers of Jesus to work towards a just and fair society by bringing about social and political change. It is actually a combination of Christian theology and Marxist beliefs that strives to relieve political and social oppression from the oppressed of society.           The reason that this caught my attention so much was that, to me, it finally seemed like the Catholic Church was acting in how I view it should. Throughout history the Catholic Church has been a business, seemingly only interested in their own gain. They even functioned as the ban...
Read more

Making a Mexican Identity

-
          In Professor Stark's part of the class, the discussion of Mexico has seemed to have one common motif throughout the whole conversation - the struggle to create a national identity. But, from hearing the state that Mexico was in at the time, it is not surprising that they were struggling so much to create a unified identity. There were two parts of that struggle that really stuck out to me - the sheer size and spread of the land that they were trying to unite, and trying to incorporate the indigenous into their society.           The amount of territory that Mexico used to possess blows my mind. It was such a huge expanse of land, so much so that the climate and geography differed drastically from one area to the next. In all of present-day California, there were a total of 3,000 people. I put that into perspective for myself by thinking about the fact that there were 1,200 students in my high school alone, being the smallest o...
Read more

The Construction of the Helpless Female

-
          The political cartoons that we have been looking at for Professor Serrata's part of the class really have me thinking. I keep thinking about Cuba being portrayed as the "damsel in distress" and what that signified and continues to signify today. In the context of the time period (the late 19th century to beginning 20th century), we can understand a bit that yes, women were considered to be inferior to men, and yes, this accurately portrays what the illustrator was trying to say about Cuba. But what is sad is that even in our 21st century mindset, we can still see that - that Cuba is portrayed as a woman because, in a lot of cases, women are considered to be inferior to men. This is not how it should be!           This even relates back to way in the beginning of the year when we talked about the difference between sex and gender, and how gender is really just a construct that we as people of the society have dictated. But it i...
Read more